The Oppressor Class

Phoebe Maltz nails it, discussing the creation of a late 19th century German colony established, in part, to keep good Aryans away from those meddlesome Jews:

Anti-Semites weren’t - aren’t - just people who think they’re better than Jews. They’re people who think they’re being oppressed by Jews.

This is part of the reason why anti-Semitism so easily finds footing among certain branches of the far-left. To be sure, it’s also why anti-Semitism finds footing among the far-right — the right certainly has no trouble imagining untrustworthy aliens who threaten Our Way of Life. But the left’s rhetoric of opposing “oppression” and “hierarchy” can easily incorporate anti-Semitic prejudices insofar as they buy into popular narratives of Jews and the quintessential oppressing class.

This also relates to some popular prescriptions of how Jews can end anti-Semitism (much like ending rape or ending racism, this is of course typically presented as the obligation of the victim rather than the perpetrator). Jews will cease being hated when they cease possessing power, whether it be social (control of Hollywood), political (“the Jewish lobby”), national (Israel), or what have you. See, for example, this piece of work (proof that finding yourself on a Google Book Search isn’t always a happy day).  A Jew who has the temerity to succeed (and in particular, succeed at persuading others) is a Jew who is playing to stereotype. A polity where Jews are successfully convincing non-Jews to adopt policies Jews find amenable is a polity that clearly,clearly, has been damaged or diseased in some way. How else could Jews possibly win but by dirty pool?

The corollary is that Jews have a normative obligation to be weak, to be at the sufferance of others. It is wrong for Jews to win, and it is extra wrong for Jews to win based on their own decisions and determinations (as opposed to being gifted a privilege by the benevolent majority). Jewish power is always taken to be Jewish oppression; hence, the bare fact that Jews sometimes are in a position where they don’t have to answer to the Gentile world is itself an outrage. This is why so much of the “critical” (so to speak) assault on Jewish institutions focuses not on what they do, but the fact of their continued existence. That Jews have institutions which can make decisions which impact the world without —gasp— gentile permission; this is the anathema. The problem is when Jews are subjects — actors who have the ability to influence the world around them. The solution is to make them subjects — subjugated and controlled by others who know best.


  1. fy-socialjustice reblogged this from this-is-not-jewish
  2. bisexualnikita reblogged this from littlegoythings
  3. queerdybbuk reblogged this from libhobn and added:
    #they will stop hating us when we abdicate all power#even the power of self-determine
  4. screamingcreaming reblogged this from bisexualtransgirlsmellerbee
  5. skypalacearchitect reblogged this from chicagojewgirl
  6. libhobn reblogged this from littlegoythings
  7. chicagojewgirl reblogged this from bisexualtransgirlsmellerbee
  8. bisexualtransgirlsmellerbee reblogged this from littlegoythings
  9. kankurette reblogged this from littlegoythings
  10. goatwishes reblogged this from littlegoythings
  11. littlegoythings reblogged this from schraubd
  12. wombatking reblogged this from blardenfrazifonochip
  13. blardenfrazifonochip reblogged this from schraubd
  14. adrivenleaf reblogged this from schraubd
  15. konnichiwahabibisan reblogged this from schraubd
  16. lavendergaia reblogged this from iwaharamovin
  17. jamesbarnnes reblogged this from iwaharamovin
  18. iwaharamovin reblogged this from therapsida
  19. kuklarusskaya reblogged this from teabooksandchocolate and added:
    omg this is brilliant YES YES YES
  20. arealmra reblogged this from optimistic-red-velvet-walrus
  21. upside-downchristopherrobin reblogged this from hesdeadjim
  22. whatisdoneisinprogress reblogged this from axonsandsynapses
  23. axonsandsynapses reblogged this from sepiacircus and added:
    THIS. I mean, that is not to say that Jews don’t experience privilege (most American Jews have white or white-passing...
  24. quietprofanity reblogged this from this-is-not-jewish
  25. toasthaste reblogged this from brainstatic and added:
    This is pretty interesting. I’ve definitely noticed proud antisemitism in people who are otherwise pretty okay and...
  26. tassledown reblogged this from this-is-not-jewish and added:
    Wow, this was an interesting and disturbingly truthful read. Do check it out. Become enlightened. Stop being nutsacks...